Shanghai to Challenge HK on IPO’s
It seems the latest buzz is how Shanghai is set to challenge Hong Kong’s status as the world’s IPO “fund-raising king.” CNBC, Bloomberg, China Daily, Reuters, etc are all talking about it. CSA asks, is this a legitimate claim?
It is difficult to argue with the numbers. According to this article, HK is expected to raise about $47.7 billion this year in 2010, while Shanghai is predicted will attract about $55.7 billion.
The key question to ask is, who is raising this money? Hong Kong has the institutions, history and legal framework for international company’s to list on its bourse, while Shanghai does not. In other words, the mainland may attract more money in IPO’s, but the money is going to be raised primarily by mainland company’s–specifically ones state owned entities.
Shanghai is preparing a international board which will allow foreign company’s to list on the mainland but, when this will come online is anybody’s guess. Shanghai still lacks a developed insurance market, many private company’s on the mainland fear listing because of the potential of being forced to pay higher taxes after they make their accounting public / transparent, margin trading and short-selling is limited, the bond market is small, and stock market futures were only introduced today (see this Bloomberg article).
Nonetheless, there are company’s working on getting access to Shanghai. The China Daily reports the first company’s which are hoping to list on the mainland’s A-share market are HSBC and the global exchange group NYSE-Euronext. HSBC, is essentially the main player in HK’s HengSeng inde, while NYSE-Euronext represent the investors vehicle for investing in shares of the New York Stock Exchange its its European Counterpart. Once again CSA asks, “where do regular company’s from abroad fit into this context?
In this article from the China Daily, Terence Ho, a analyst with Ernst & Young explains “Currently, the two places have different roles. Hong Kong caters to millions of international investors while Shanghai mainly targets domestic investors. In the short term, Shanghai is unlikely catch up with Hong Kong in terms of international exposure and liquidity.”
CSA is inclined to agree with Mr. Ho, the two markets do have different roles at the moment. As hungry as company’s around the world are tap mainland capital, China would rather have both financial centers fill different niches at the moment.
Shanghai will only come to dominate the Hong Kong’s IPO market once its financial services expand and it develops the framework for facilitating the listing of international company’s on the mainland.



